Wellness Tips

Should Every Woman Get an Annual Pelvic Ultrasound?

After 18 years as an OB-GYN, Dr. Jen explains why a pelvic ultrasound that helps one patient isn’t the same as screening every healthy woman — what the PLCO and UKCTOCS trials found, the real harms of false positives, which symptoms deserve evaluation, and why disagreement shouldn’t mean attack.

Nov 18, 2026

·

9 minutes

Should Every Woman Get an Annual Pelvic Ultrasound?

I spent 18 years practicing clinical medicine as an OB-GYN, caring for more than 3,000 women. I’ve ordered thousands of pelvic ultrasounds. I was also trained to do my own pelvic ultrasounds, so I would describe myself as very “pro-ultrasound” in gynecology. I’ve found abnormalities that needed further evaluation, and, yes, I’ve diagnosed serious conditions because of what I saw on an ultrasound in women who had symptoms. (More on that later.) I caught early bladder cancer. I diagnosed endometrial hyperplasia, a condition that can be a precursor to uterine cancer. And I often ordered a baseline pelvic ultrasound when a woman entered menopause, because I wanted to have something to compare it to if she developed symptoms years later.

In those years with all those patients, I never diagnosed or saw a single case of ovarian cancer or endometrial cancer in a routine sonogram in a woman without symptoms. Not one.

I share that not because I think ovarian and endometrial cancer are unimportant. Quite the opposite. They are devastating diseases. Ovarian cancer is often diagnosed at an advanced stage, and we desperately need better tools to detect it earlier. I share it because my personal experience, even after nearly two decades of practicing medicine, is just that. My experience. It is not a clinical trial, and it is not population-based scientific evidence.

And that brings me to something that has been bothering me lately, both as a physician and, frankly, as a human being.

When did disagreeing with someone become a reason to attack them?

I’ve watched doctors, researchers, and scientists get absolutely eviscerated online for explaining medical evidence that people simply don’t want to hear. People attack me similarly, but I’m used to dealing with this after 20 years with a national platform. The keyboard courage is remarkable. People who would never dream of speaking to someone that way in person suddenly feel perfectly comfortable questioning a physician’s integrity, intelligence, compassion, or motives because the science doesn’t align with their personal beliefs or experiences.

And here’s what really gets me. You can care deeply about women, believe their stories, want to prevent every single cancer death, AND recognize that a particular screening test doesn’t work the way we wish it did. Those things are not mutually exclusive. Stating you are for or against a test does not make you for or against women.

Somewhere along the way, we’ve confused disagreement with disrespect, scientific uncertainty with incompetence, and evidence-based medicine with a lack of compassion. I think that’s a far bigger problem. We have become so uncomfortable listening to people whose opinions differ from our own that we’d rather attack the messenger than consider the message.

That isn’t curiosity. It isn’t advocacy. And it certainly isn’t how science advances.

Why this matters so much in the conversation about pelvic ultrasounds and cancer screening

Hundreds of women have shared stories with me about asking for an ultrasound or randomly having one done, sometimes having to push for one, and ultimately discovering a cancer. I believe them. Every single one. I understand their gratitude, their fear, and sometimes their anger. If an ultrasound helped save your life, I would never try to diminish that experience. I’d be grateful right alongside you.

But an individual medical success story and a recommendation for screening tens of millions of healthy women are two entirely different things. This distinction is fundamental to medicine, and it’s one that often gets lost on social media.

When I was practicing, I wasn’t treating a population. I was treating the woman sitting across from me. I knew her medical history, her family history, her symptoms, her fears, and sometimes things about her life that she’d never told anyone else. I could make an individualized clinical decision to order an ultrasound because, for that particular woman, at that particular moment, I believed the information might be helpful. I was also confident in my own clinical experience and judgment in terms of interpreting those ultrasounds, so I felt that the benefits outweighed the risks, and I discussed all of this with every single patient.

That’s the art and science of clinical medicine.

Public health is different. Public health asks what happens when we recommend the same intervention to hundreds of thousands or millions of people, most of whom have no symptoms and no disease. It doesn’t just ask whether a test can find something. It asks whether using that test routinely actually saves lives, and whether the benefits outweigh the potential harms, which include costs (both to the individual and to the healthcare system).

And yes, there can be tension between these two worlds. What makes sense for one patient doesn’t automatically make sense as a recommendation for an entire population.

That is not a contradiction. That’s medicine.

For a test to qualify as an effective population screening tool, it needs to identify disease accurately (which sonograms do not do reliably), detect it at a stage when treatment can improve outcomes (sonograms may or may not accomplish this), and produce more benefit than harm. Finding cancer is important. But finding cancers earlier is not, by itself, proof that a screening program saves lives.

For ovarian cancer, we have studied this extensively

The two landmark trials, PLCO in the United States and UKCTOCS in the United Kingdom, collectively enrolled more than a quarter of a million women. They investigated pelvic ultrasound, the CA-125 blood test, or combinations of screening strategies.

And what did they find? Some cancers were detected earlier, but screening did not significantly reduce deaths from ovarian cancer. Let that sink in. We could sometimes detect the disease earlier, but we couldn't demonstrate that screening saved more women’s lives.

And the harms were not theoretical. In the PLCO trial, more than 3,000 women had false-positive screening results. Of those, 1,080 underwent surgery despite not having ovarian cancer, and approximately 15% of those women experienced a serious surgical complication. So when hundreds of Instagram comments asked me what the risks of getting an ultrasound are, that is precisely the risk that we are concerned with. Serious surgical complications… for an unnecessary surgery performed because of a false-positive ultrasound finding.

These were real women. With real operations, real recoveries, and real complications. All because of a test that ultimately failed to demonstrate the outcome we wanted most: fewer women dying of ovarian cancer.

That’s why the US Preventive Services Task Force recommends against routine ovarian cancer screening in women without symptoms, and no major medical group recommends routine endometrial cancer screening for women at average risk. Not because doctors don't care. Not because women’s health isn’t a priority. And certainly not because anyone thinks ovarian cancer isn’t worth finding. It’s because we care about what happens to women AFTER the test, too.

Uterine cancer is a different situation. For women at average risk, routine ultrasound screening isn’t recommended, in part because abnormal uterine bleeding, especially after menopause, is often an early warning sign. And that symptom needs evaluation. An ultrasound can be an excellent diagnostic tool in that setting, often followed by an endometrial biopsy when indicated.

And this is where individual clinical judgment matters enormously

A woman with persistent bloating, pelvic pressure, early satiety, or unexplained urinary changes deserves to be evaluated. A woman with postmenopausal bleeding deserves a workup. A woman with a BRCA mutation, Lynch syndrome, or a strong family history needs a different conversation about genetic counseling, the limits of surveillance, and possibly risk-reducing surgery. Other risk factors, like obesity or never having children, are worth discussing with your doctor too.

But please understand that using ultrasound as a diagnostic tool, or ordering one based on an individualized clinical assessment, is not the same thing as recommending an annual ultrasound for every healthy woman in America (which is what a gynecologist recently did on Mel Robbins’s podcast).

The first is practicing medicine. The second is establishing a public health screening policy. They require different levels of evidence, but the communication skills for both should be the same: professional, calm, not fear-based or hyperbolic, and fully transparent in terms of explaining what we know and what we don’t know.

And I wish we could talk about that difference without turning it into a fight. Because underneath all of this is something deeply emotional: fear. Fear of missing a cancer. Fear of being the woman whose symptoms were dismissed. Fear of trusting a doctor and finding out later that something was overlooked. I understand that fear, especially when women have spent generations feeling unheard or dismissed by the medical establishment. That history is real, and it deserves acknowledgment. But fear can also lead us toward medical interventions that feel reassuring without necessarily making us safer.

An ultrasound may provide reassurance. It may also identify an incidental cyst that would have disappeared on its own; trigger months of anxiety, repeat testing, and extra costs; or even result in an unnecessary operation. More testing is not always better medicine. And less testing does not automatically mean less caring.

I don’t expect everyone to agree with me. In fact, I welcome thoughtful disagreement. Medicine has evolved because people challenged conventional wisdom, asked difficult questions, and demanded better evidence. I have changed my own medical opinions when better data became available. That’s what we’re supposed to do.

We need to be able to hold both truths at once. If your ultrasound found your cancer, your story matters. If a physician explains why that same ultrasound should not be recommended as a routine screening test for millions of asymptomatic women, that physician's explanation matters, too. Neither invalidates the other.

Here’s what I want women to take away from this conversation

Know your family history. Pay attention to your body. Understand which symptoms deserve evaluation, and don’t ignore persistent changes. If you feel something is wrong, advocate for yourself. Ask questions. Get another opinion if your concerns aren’t being addressed. But please don't let social media convince you that every test you aren’t getting represents a failure of medical care, or that every physician who disagrees with a popular health claim is somehow against women.

I’ve spent my entire professional life advocating for women’s health. I know how imperfect medicine can be. I’ve seen its extraordinary successes and its heartbreaking limitations. And I know that we have a long way to go when it comes to detecting ovarian cancer early enough to save more lives.

The answer to imperfect science isn’t to abandon science—it’s to demand better science

While we’re at it, perhaps we could demand a little more respect for one another as well.

We can disagree without attacking. We can question without insulting. We can listen without surrendering our own beliefs. And we can care passionately about women’s health without allowing fear and anger to drive every medical decision.

I don’t know when listening to someone we disagree with became such a lost art. But I think it’s one we desperately need to recover. Because the goal here isn’t to win an argument on Instagram. The goal is to save women’s lives. And that should be something we can all agree on.

‍

Share this article

×
Today’s Ajenda · Free weekly email

Articles like this, in your inbox every week.

Dr. Jen’s science-backed take on women’s health, weight, nutrition and wellness. No fluff, no fads. Every Wednesday, free.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.Keep reading